Review | CoverGirl So Lashy! Mascara

I’m sure you’ve seen all the promotions and commercials for the new CoverGirl mascara called So Lashy! BlastPRO. CoverGirl recently became the first major makeup brand to feature a male in their advertising campaign, smashing stereotypes and introducing the world to the concept of men in makeup. While I applaud their decision to take the first step in recognizing men in the beauty industry and putting James Charles out there as the face of the brand, I unfortunately don’t applaud their newest mascara.

I received the CoverGirl So Lashy BlastPRO mascara complimentary by Influenster in return for my honest review. You know me…. always honest, no matter what! CoverGirl makes the following claims about this mascara:

Get the bold, dark, voluminous lashes you’ve dreamed of with COVERGIRL So Lashy! BlastPRO Mascara. Our 3-in-1 brush shapes, molds and builds lashes regardless of your lash type, while the specialized ball tip gets the corners and hard to reach lashes. It’s the perfect mascara for any occasion.

BlastPro is available in 5 shades: Extreme Black, Intense Black, Jet Black, Black, Black Brown. It is available in waterproof, although the formula I tested is not waterproof. I typically only wear waterproof formula mascaras since I wear contacts, and I tend to suffer from allergies and eye irritation quite often. Even without any of those issues, if I don’t wear a waterproof formula, it eventually finds its way down the front of my face, making it look like I have two big black eyes or am crying tears of mascara. I kept an open mind and gave his formula a try,  especially considering all the hype it’s received.

Cover Girl So Lashy Mascara

I conducted my test on a low-key day when I wasn’t wearing a full face of makeup.  The applicator has one of those strange “balls” at the top of it, which CoverGirl says will grab any stray lashes and ensure they’re all completely coated with mascara. I think it’s a little strange, definitely not helpful for me personally. It caused more problems than it helped; I accidentally got the formula on my upper eyelid while trying to maneuver their funky wand.  The formula itself seemed very thin, not clumpy. That’s all the positive news I can muster up about this mascara.

I have pretty long lashes to begin with, but as I age, they’re becoming more and more difficult to see unless I wear mascara. This formula gave me a very basic coating that helped me see my lashes, but it didn’t make them stand out or pop. It didn’t appear to lengthen them, help preserve the curl, or add any volume whatsoever. My lashes appeared as thin as always, just a little more visible, with a very natural appearance. Where was the vava voom? It was clearly missing.

Cover Girl So Lashy Mascara Wand

When I wear a mascara, I want my lashes to say “HELLO…. LOOK AT ME!”  If I wanted a subtle, completely natural look, I wouldn’t wear mascara at all. A good mascara should give the lashes volume, length, and make them stand out. So Lashy did none of those things. I only wore the mascara for a 6 hour test. At the end of the 6 hours, I had dark circles of mascara under my eyes and on my eyelids from transfer. It didn’t stay on my lashes where it belonged but instead proceeded to transfer onto my skin with every blink of my eyes. By this time, I was ready to wash my face and remove all traces of black mascara from my face and eyes. This experience was unfortunately a big disappointment for me personally, but as with all cosmetic products, what doesn’t work for me may work great for others!


Photos – After 6 Hours of Wear
Test Photo
After 6 hours of wear. Note the dark product transfer under the eyes (raccoon eyes).
After Photo
The product transferred onto my entire upper eyelid and to the bottom of my eyes. No, my eyes aren’t normally this dark.
After 6 Hours
After only 6 hours, hardly any mascara remains on my lashes.

Hit or Miss? Total miss!

Price: $10.49 (prices vary)

Where to Buy:  Available at Ulta.  Or any drugstore where Cover Girl products are sold


Legal Disclaimer: The content on this site is for informational and entertainment purposes only. All opinions are my own. The information contained within this blog is subject to change without notice. None of the opinions expressed are intended to harm or malign any religion, ethnic group, organization, company, or individual. All content is protected by copyright, and any unauthorized use, reproduction, copying, republishing or duplication is prohibited without the expressed written permission of the owner. Unless otherwise stated, all photos are the work and property of MyBeautifulFlaws and are protected by copyright. Images may not be copied, edited, or otherwise used/republished without expressed written permission from MyBeautifulFlaws, the blog owner. To obtain permission to copy portions of the content within this blog, please send an email to The blog contains some (not all) affiliate links, in which I will earn a small commission if you use to make a purchase. This commission is used to support the ongoing expenses of the blog.

1 Comment

  1. Christina
    May 22, 2017 / 8:28 am

    Hey! I know your having a not so great day (or night sorry) so I’m going to go back through some of your posts and tell you what I loved about them!! I might only be able to do a couple tonight as its getting a bit late here in Australia, but I’ll be back tomorrow to do some more! This blog post is a perfect example of what I was saying on your Instagram post.. Your blog is so refreshing because I know that I’m going to get an honest review of a product! You don’t feel the need (unlike so many other influencers do unfortunately) to give a product a good review because you’ve been sent the product by the company and I really respect that!! I’m a sucker for a good drugstore mascara but thanks to your honest, no bullshit review, I knew to avoid this one!
    ❤️ – @christinashaw96

Leave a Comment and Share Your Thoughts Below!